Unofficial Document
June 2002
The following document presented by Dr. Nabil Shaath to the US Secretary of State Powell and deals with the Palestinian vision for the final settlement:
"At this critical time when the international community is seeking to
formulate a comprehensive policy regarding the Middle East, the PA believes
that it is important to convey the Palestinian vision for ending the
Palestinian-Israeli conflict. While many creative and constructive ideas
regarding ending the current crisis are being presented, we believe that
these ideas will not succeed if they are not accompanied by a clear
political horizon that will rekindle hope in a permanent peace based on a
negotiated solution.
The Palestinian vision below had been discussed with our Arab friends, in
particular Egypt, Jordan and Saudi Arabia, all of whom share our opinion
regarding the centrality of a vision of peace to the success of any efforts.
The Arab Peace Initiative of March 2002, along with The vision of President
Bush, Secretary of State Colin Powell's speech of November 2001, and UN
Security Council Resolutions 242, 338, and 1397, are the bases of the
Palestinian vision for a permanent status agreement between Palestine and
Israel. According to these bases, the following are the main elements of our
vision:
The borders between the state of Palestine and the state of Israel will be
the June 4th 1967 Armistice Line, though the two sides may agree to monitor,
reciprocal, and equal modifications that do not affect, among other things,
contiguity. The Palestinian and Israeli sides have no territorial clams
beyond the June 4, 1967 borders. These borders will be the permanent
boundaries between the two states.
There will be a permanent territorial link established between the West Bank
and the Gaza Strip sections of the state of Palestine.
East Jerusalem will become the capital of the State of Palestine and West
Jerusalem will become the capital of the State of Israel.
Jerusalem, which is venerated by the three monotheistic religions, will
remain open to all peoples.
The Palestinian side will transfer sovereignty over the Jewish Quarter and
the Wailing Wall section of the Western Wall in East Jerusalem to Israel,
while retaining sovereignty over the remainder of the Old City.
Palestine and Israel will establish security cooperation arrangements that
preserve the integrity and sovereignty of each state.
International forces will play a central role in these arrangements. In
addition, the two sides will strive to establish a regional security regime.
Neither Palestine nor Israel will participate in military alliances against
each other, or allow their territory to be used as a military base of
operation against each other or against other neighbors. No foreign troops
may be stationed in the territory of either state unless otherwise specified
in the permanent status agreement or subsequently agreed to by the two
parties. Palestine and Israel's respective sovereignty and independence will
be guarantees by formal agreements with members of the international
community.
Palestine will agree to limits in the armaments it will possess.
In accordance with the Arab Peace Initiative of March 2002, there will be a
just and agreed solution to the Palestinian refugee problem based on UN
General Assembly Resolution 194.
The issue of water will be resolved in a just and equitable manner in
accordance with accepted international norms.
Palestine and Israel will be democratic states with free market economies.
The comprehensive permanent status agreement will mark the end of conflict
between Palestine and Israel, and its complete implementation will mark the
end of claims between them.
Naturally, the realization of this vision requires a parallel process that
will create concrete and positive developments on the ground. These will
require a policy of de-escalation, de-occupation, ensuring the protection of
Palestinian and Israeli peoples in accordance with the rule of law, and the
gradual introduction of attributes of sovereignty to buttress and prepare
the ground for a permanent status agreement.
There should be a fixed timeline for this process with guaranteed diplomatic
involvement in order to ensure that the process does not stall. Part of
preparing for eventual Palestinian statehood requires internal Palestinian
restructuring, which we have already embarked on in the political, financial
and security fields. In the security realm, the ideas suggested by CIA
Director George Tenet will be the basis of our efforts.