This is a humanitarian crisis without precedent in its destructive
impact on the Palestinian people and its institutions,?
Joint statement on the humanitarian crisis in the Occupied
Territories, from United Nations organizations, including UNDP,
UNFPA, World Health Organization, UN High Commission for
Refugees, International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent
and UNWRA, among others. Rome, 10 April 2002**
This is a very preliminary inventory of damage done to Palestinian
public institutions by the Israeli army in the course of its invasion of
Palestinian cities and villages that began March 29th. The
information will undoubtedly be augmented by reports from
throughout the West Bank once more on-the-ground investigations
are possible and when communication systems are working again.
Indeed, this report overwhelmingly focuses on institutions in
Ramallah, due to the fact that temporary liftings of the ongoing
curfew have allowed individuals to make preliminary inspections of
institutions once they are no longer occupied by IDF forces. The
main focus here is particularly on ministries and other institutions of
the Palestinian Authority, while ongoing information is being
collected on non-governmental organizations, and the media.
However, even the initial findings indicate several disturbing patterns
with very grave consequences. In particular, institutions of the
Palestinian Authority have been subjected to a consistent pattern of
incursions which focus on seizure of records and financial resources
and destruction of technical infrastructure. There has been a
consistent pattern of seizure of documents, hard disk from
computers, paper files as well as widespread vandalism. In addition,
is what we have called- œsanctioned theft? “ seizing of equipment
which has no informational or intelligence value, as well as some
theft of money. The private media has also been subject to
extensive and systematic destruction of its technical facilities. The
evidence suggests a policy of de-institutionalizing all Palestinian
media “ and not just that of the PNA but Palestine™s vibrant
independent TV and radio sector, as well. The limited data on
destruction and theft of non-governmental organizations, is also
reported. Due to the limited data available, it is less clear if the
organizations themselves are specific targets or whether they are
primarily victims of general searches, IDF occupation of buildings for
barracks, sniper positions, or lookouts.
The interim agreements between Israel and the Palestine Liberation
Organization, and the fragile, if flawed, peace that ensued, ushered
in a period of Palestinian institution-building that was unprecedented
in scale, although drawing on the rich experience of developing local
institutions, particularly non-governmental organizations, during the
period of direct Israeli military occupation. While the Palestinian
Authority admittedly had very limited sovereignity, powers and
territory, for the first time a Palestinian government authority
directed Palestinian education, health, civil affairs and social
services, among other functions and responsibilities, and began to
plan for economic and social development. Elections were held in
January 1996 for the first elected Palestinian parliament which
brought into being the 88-member Palestinian Legislative Council
and elected Yasser Arafat as President. When Israeli policy and
military action is directed at œdismantling? the Palestinian Authority, it
not only targets political leaders and institutions of self-rule, but it
also targets vital services for the survival of Palestinian society, un-
doing developmental projects and initiatives crucial to a stable and
democratic Palestinian future.
Palestinian institution-building was strongly supported by the
international community; donor funds to Palestinian governmental
and non-governmental institutions in the 1995-2000 period
amounted to 3,313,719,000 USD of which 933,411USD went for
social spending, particularly education and health. Up until October
2000, the Authority also steadily increased its own revenue
collection. Even in the difficult conditions of siege and closure of the
second intifada and the refusal of the Israeli government to transfer
owed revenue clearances to the Authority (its most important source
of revenues), it is vital, as the World Bank and UNSCO state, œto
recognize the essential functions and achievements of the
Palestinian Authority in providing basic essential services under very
adverse conditions during the past five months? (World Bank and
UNSCO 4 April 2002). The incursions into the Ministries of
Education, Finances and Civil Affairs, as well as the municipalities,
noted below, certainly threaten these services and should be of
great concern.
The report is based on phone interviews with individuals who were
able to make on-site visits as well as reports issued by institutions
that were able to make preliminary inspections themselves. It
includes only those institutions that could be physically surveyed for
damage. Institutions that are still occupied by Israeli military forces
(as stated in the report), are included only if the external
assessment gives some indication of the extent of probable
damage. The ongoing curfew in all of the towns invaded by the IDF
has been the main obstacle to collecting information.
Ramallah PNA institutions
Ministry of Civil Affairs
The Legislative Council (PLC)
Ministry of Education
Central Bureau of Statistics
Ministry of Finance
Ramallah/ El Bireh Local Government
Municipality of Ramallah
Municipality of al Bireh
Al Bireh Municipal Library
Ramallah District Chamber of Commerce
Ramallah Non-governmental Institutions
1. Human Rights Organizations: al Haq, Mattin Group and Mandela
Institute
2.Development and Relief Organizations: HDIP and Union
of Medical Relief Committees, Ramallah branch of the YMCA,
3. Private Radio and Television Stations: al Quds University
Educational T.V. and Radio and others in Ramallah
Other Towns:
Bethlehem Municipality,
Anabta Municipality and two community organizations
Tulkarm General Union of Palestinian Women Office
At this time there is no further information available on the fate
of other occupied or invaded Ministries in Ramallah which
include:
Ministry of Culture (IDF continues to occupy it since Friday March
29)
Ministry of Information (IDF continues to occupy it since Friday
March 29)
Ministry of Interior (Inside Presidents Compound: shelled -- amount
of destruction unknown)
Ministry of Agriculture (occupied by IDF April 12th exited April 13)
Ministry of Social Affairs (occupied by IDF today April 13)
Health Secretariat (occupied and exited by IDF April 13th)
General Personnel Office (occupied and exited by IDF April 13)
At this time there is no further information on reported damage
or IDF occupation of the following Ramallah-based NGOs:
al Damir, prisoners rights organization; al Mawarid Educational
resource Center; Law human rights organization, Sakakini Cultural
Center (invaded April 13th); The Young Scientists Club, The
Agricultural Relief Committees.
The following NGOs have been invaded by IDF (and visited by
staff when curfew lifted) but have only suffered mild damage
from searches includes: MUWATEN, Birzeit Continuing Education
Program, Birzeit Institute of Music.
RAMALLAH:
I. NATIONAL GOVERNMENT (PNA) INSTITUTIONS:
This preliminary report only covers civil institutions of government
and has not attempted to deal with the widespread destruction of
Palestinian Police stations and other security force installations.
RAMALLAH
1. Ministry of Civil Affairs
Location: Um al Sharayat
The Ministry of Civil Affairs is headed by Minister Jamil al Tarifi. It is
the main address for Palestinians living outside the occupied
territories who want to apply for visitor permits, family re-unification
and residency permits. It also handles the customs and other
administrative details for Palestinian returnees. As such, most of its
work is done in liason with Israeli officials who vet every application.
The Ministry is housed in a five story building and divided into six
departments.
Damage: Extensive vandalism, some confiscation of materials and
some theft.
From a preliminary on-sight report by Ministry employees the
following description was provided. The main doors to the Ministry
were blown open (evidence of a blast), inside the main entrance
reception area were the remains of a large pile of burnt documents.
Equipment: Inside the two sections that were visited thus far (there
are six sections altogether), destroyed Xerox copiers (seem to be
sledge hammered) as well as destroyed computers and printers.
The central phone exchange taken as well as a digital receiver in
the Ministers office.
Confiscation of Records: Thus far some missing hard drives, but
stolen papers from especially the Ministers office (neighbors told the
employee they saw soldiers carrying out what seemed to be boxes
of papers). Many destroyed documents.
Theft: Door to Minister's office blown open, the safe inside also
blown open and its contents including documents and Ministry
finances missing. Petty cash of 6,000 shekels taken from the
finance department.
Other: The employee stated that the entrance and offices she
entered were in complete disarray and severely vandalized. Besides
broken equipment, broken filing cabinets and papers strewn
everywhere -- many internal windows were smashed as well.
Additionally, pictures on walls (especially with Palestinian themes)
were found on the floor smashed. Also graffiti sprayed on walls. The
employee stated that she was so horrified at the extent of the
damage and vandalism that she was unable to visit more of the
building and left in tears.
2. MINISTRY OF EDUCATION
Location: Ramallah / Masyun district
The Ministry serves about one million children, i.e. a third of the total
Palestinian population of the West Bank and Gaza. It is the main
address for the overall administration of all government primary and
secondary schools, their faculties, as well as archiving of student
transcripts. On April 3rd at approximately 4:00 p.m. 30 APC's and
tanks carrying approximately 150 soldiers broke down the ministry's
main gates. Four employees in the Ministry were taken to open
doors, in some cases when they had no keys doors were exploded
open or broken open. Reports suggest that at other times even
when staff offered to open doors they were ignored while soldiers
forcibly broke in. Staff were made to stand outside in the cold for
more than six hours while soldiers were inside the building.
Damage: Extensive vandalism, theft and confiscation
External Damage: IDF tanks demolished the main gate to the
building and the main doors of the premises were forced open.
Internal Damage:The IDF forces vandalized the Ministry's offices,
confiscating computers and educational aids and removing or
destroying vital records and documents. Although it has not been
possible for the Ministry to assess the full damage and destruction
wrought, the following specific damage was noted by Ministry
employees who were able to make a brief room by room survey of
the damage when the curfew was lifted for a few hours.
General: the Ministry's computer net servers were removed
financial office: the main safe was blown open damaging its
contents, including dossiers, promissory notes, cash, check books
and vouchers
-central office: the Israeli forces blew up metal filing cabinets
destroying vital documents.
- all offices: files have been torn up, and left in huge piles on the
floor
- Storage room: the IDF confiscated computers, overhead
projectors, video sets, and other valuable educational equipment
- Central office: The Israeli forces blew up and destroyed all main
doors. They took away or destroyed records and references that
are highly important for official transcripts.
- Remaining offices in the Ministry: The forces seem to have
confiscated many floppy disks, CDs, files, dossiers and documents
but more time will be needed to more accurately assess.
Impact
The Ministry's records, which were confiscated or destroyed, have
been built up over many years. The Ministry hopes it will be able to
re-construct destroyed records for the issuing and certifying of
students' transcripts from regional MOE offices.The MOE is unable
to gain full and clear access to the premises in order to make a
comprehensive and detailed assessment of the damage and losses
at this point. However, it estimates the financial loss merely of
equipment, such as computers, videos, TV sets and overhead
projectors, to reach millions of dollars. Most of this equipment was
financed by donor countries and organizations.The main and direct
impact of this destruction, however, is on the one million Palestinian
children who are enrolled in the school system and who constitute
the main resource of Palestinian society in the future.
This data is based on a fuller report undertaken by the Ministry itself.
For the full text please contact Acting Minister of Education
Dr. Naim Abu Hommos,
Email moepalestine@hotmail.com
Fax + 970 298 3222
3. Palestinian Legislative Council (al-Bireh and Ramallah)
The Palestinian Legislative Council (or parliament) has two main
buildings within el-Bireh/ Ramallah. The al-Bireh building is the main
administrative office of the PLC while the Assembly Chambers are
based in Ramallah in the Ministry of Education.
A. Main Administrative Building in al- Bireh
Damage: Vandalism, Confiscation and Sanctioned Theft
Based on an on-site visit by the PLC director general, and two PLC
staff, as well as witnesses in the neighborhood, the following
preliminary report can be made. Israeli troops broke in late Tuesday
night, around 1:00 a.m. on Wednesday, April 10.The actual break-in
was witnessed by neighbors living across the street from the PLC
building.
Destruction: Soldiers broke into the main entrance and subsequently
the door and glass partition of the Economic Committee, the Budget
Committee, the Political Committee, and the Legal Committee. Most
of the damage included breaking and removal of doors and
windows. Some equipment was damaged and broken.
Sanctioned Theft: A computer and many files were taken from the
Speaker™s Office. A computer was also taken from the technical
departments office.
Confiscation: Files and documents taken from the Speakers office
and the Chief Clerks office. Hard drives taken from computers. All
the computers were open in the personnel department.
Vandalism: The Library and the Public Relations Unit have suffered
extensive vandalism, books and files were thrown all over the floor.
The door of the "Hansard" (sound and video equipment) office was
broken, documents were thrown on the floor, but the equipment was
left intact.
The IT Unit, Information Department, and Director™s General office
did not sustain any damage. Cars and vehicles parked on the
streets were damaged, and troops took keys of vehicles from the
Technical Department. Telephones are operating at the Council,
and the Council has electricity.
(The above information is based on ARD report provided by Dr.
Mahmoud Labadi, PLC director general, and two PLC staff Faisal
Zakarneh, and Ahmad Abu Dayyeh, along with Amin Sbeih of
ARD/PLC2 project)
B. Legislative Council Chambers in Ramallah Ministry of Education
Building
The Chambers of the Legislative Council are where the 88
members meet when the PLC is in session. The Chamber
auditorium includes not only seating for the council members, but
expensive technical equipment for computerized voting, video
coverage of sessions and a closed circuit communications system
to link it with the administrative building in el-Bireh.
Damage: Destroyed Doors; Confiscation of Video Archive of PLC
Sessions
At approximately 4:00 p.m. on April 3rd, around 150 soldiers, with 30
tanks and APCs, forced their way into the Ministry of Education™s
Compound. The soldiers detained four employees of the Ministry of
Education™s compound, including Mr. Salah Soubani, and made
them walk in front of the soldiers and open doors.
A group of about 50 soldiers forced Mr. Soubani to accompany them
to the Legislative Council Chambers, next to the elementary school,
on the grounds of the Ministry compound. They asked several
questions about the Chambers: Who attends the meetings? What
do they do in the sessions? Do people work there or live there?
Any door that could not be opened with a key, was blown up with an
explosive charge. [Several people living in the neighborhood heard
the explosions.] A door to the school was blown up and the door
between the school and the PLC Chambers was also blown up. The
soldiers looked through every room of the PLC wing. They took all of
the video-cassette tapes from the lower video room, at least a
hundred tapes of Council sessions, put them in plastic bags, and
carried them away. As far as Mr. Soubani knows, no equipment was
stolen or damaged in the raid.
The soldiers did not appear to be from a special unit. They wore
basic green army fatigues. They did not use names when they
talked to each other, instead they called each other by numbers,
except for one soldier who was repeatedly referred to as œSharon?.
When the rooms were inspected today, April 4th, Mr. Salah Soubani
confirmed that sound (Hansard) and Video equipment seemed to be
in place and intact.
The above report is based on ARD/PLC2 project interview with Mr.
Salah Soubani, director of the Information Department at the
Ministry of Education-Ramallah
4. Ministry of Finance Central Office
Location: Sateh Marhaba Area
There are three buildings of the Finance Ministry in Ramallah. The
Central Office in Suteh Marhaba has been visited by Ministry
employees once the curfew was lifted, the other two (one in the
Industrial district and one downtown) are occupied by the IDF and
cannot be visited. The Central Office houses the Ministers office as
well as a number of main departments (Accounts, Payroll, General
administration etc¦). It was broken into by a group of soldiers on
approximately the 4th day of the invasion of Ramallah according to
neighbors.
Damage: Broken doors, Extensive Confiscation of Computers and
Computer Hard Disks
Destruction: Broken entrance doors and many internal doors
destroyed, as well as windows. Elevator badly damaged. Destroyed
Computers. Destroyed furniture.
Confiscation: Computer skeletons strewn on the floor, due to many
hard disk drives being taken. The most hard hit section in terms of
taken computers and hard disks seems to be the Payroll
department. Documents strewn on the floor suggests that paper
files may have been taken but the employees did not have time to
assess. Other computers were found with their screens on.
Other comments/ Impact: The general director suggested that the
main destruction and loss was of the Ministry's financial records and
accounts. The Ministry is in charge of disbursing salaries, health and
pension payments to all government employees including teachers,
hospital workers, the police as well as government bureaucrats. The
GD says that given the loss of information, public sector employees
face not getting paid in the foreseeable future until the records can
be re-established. In addition, files for back pay and insurance may
have been lost as well.
Information based on interview with General Director Mr. Sami
Ramlawi tel. 059205038
5. Palestine Central Bureau of Statistics (PCBS)
Fieldwork Administration Section
Location: Radio Road near Lions Square (al Manara)
The Central Bureau of Statistics is headed by Dr. Hasan Abu
Libdeh. The main section of PCBS is in Balu'a area and is where
most of the statistical data bases and reports are housed, as well as
administrative records and finances. That building was invaded by
IDF troops during the first re-occupation of Ramallah in October
2001. At that time soldiers confiscated hard disks and vandalized a
number of the offices. As of this writing (April 13th) the Balu™a office
has not been touched. However, the Fieldwork section in downtown
Ramallah which serves as the administrative center for fieldwork
has been invaded on four occasions. The department is located in a
four-storey residential and commercial building and is composed of
four apartments.
Damage: (Only covers first three invasions “ as yet no confirmed
information on damage wrought by April 12th break-in). Two broken
doors, some broken windows -- both in the course of soldiers
entering into the building. Damage is relatively light and there is no
extensive vandalism.
Comment: The director of the section said that that it has been
entered by soldiers on four occasions; March 30th, April 3rd and April
8th and 12th. Based on visiting the site after the first three incursions he
thinks the main aim was general search since the apartments they
entered (two) only saw light vandalism such as broken cupboards
and some strewn papers. Equipment was not damaged. However,
neighbors report that on the most recent incursion into the building
(April 12th) they heard explosives being used.
II. LOCAL GOVERNMENT INSTITUTIONS:
We have only been able to gather preliminary information based on
on-site visits about the following:
Ramallah Muncipality
El-Bireh Minicipality
Ramallah Chamber of Commerce
El-Bireh Municipal Library
1. Ramallah Municipality
Damage: Extensive vandalism, potentially some confiscation and
theft
Ramallah Municipality is located near Clock square, it contains
departments of administration, the court room, engineering, health,
sanitation, archives, surveying and finance.
On the evening of Saturday, March 30, a contingent of Israeli
soldiers forcibly entered the Municipality and remained inside for
approximately 12 hours. The building was empty when the soldiers
entered. The main door was forced open by spraying it with over fifty
bullets of different calibers. The Municipality, was empty when
soldiers broke in, nevertheless they remained there for
approximately 12 hours.. Based on a preliminary site visit, by
municipality staff once the curfew was lifted they report the following.
"Every department was vandalized,¦ Furniture was turned over and
damaged, paper files and documents were tampered with,
dispersed and thrown to the floor, surveying plans and building
license files were destroyed, office doors were broken; glass
windows, doors and partitions were smashed, and extensive
damage was inflicted on the PCs and computer network. Many of
the PCs were damaged; the CPUs and hard disks either damaged
or taken by the soldiers, and so was the main server. Two steel
safes were blown open which contained important documents
pertaining to the work of the Municipality and some petty cash.
Internal concrete block wall partitions were destroyed, and extensive
damage was sustained by the heating, electrical and computer
cable systems."
The Municipality staff has not been able to make a complete
assessment of the damage nor determine the extent of the missing
equipment, documents and other items.
The forced intrusion into the municipality was witnessed by reporters
and guests staying at a nearby hotel.
2. Al-Bireh Municipality
Based on data provided by municipal engineers who were able to
briefly visit the building when the curfew was lifted.
Damage: Destruction of outside walls, doors, furniture, computers,
municipal works jeep destroyed, some confiscation of files and hard
disks, extensive vandalism, theft
Destruction: An IDF contingent arriving in tanks broke into the
building on the second day of Ramallah™s invasion (Saturday March
30th). The tanks broke down the outside walls of the municipality and
crushed the municipal works jeep parked outside. Entrance and
internal doors broken down. Shattered windows. Broken furniture.
Five computers destroyed (some for hard disks, others just
vandalized). Fax machine shattered.
Confiscation: A number of files seemed to be missing and at least
two hard disks taken from computers. The municipality was unable
to see what other documents were taken as yet because of the
amount of papers strewn on the floor.
Sanctioned Theft: $12,000 surveying equipment missing
Vandalism: A number of offices were in complete disarray, with overturned
furniture and broken file cabinets. Destroyed files. Computers,
central telephone system and alarm system no longer function.
3. Al-Bireh Municipal Library
Located Near al-Bireh Municipality.
The library building was visited by municipal engineers briefly when
the curfew was lifted. A contingent of soldiers invaded the building
on the second day of the invasion 30th March
Damage: Primarily vandalism, destruction of computers, broken
doors and windows, Confiscation of books and journal
Destruction: External doors, shattered windows, 3 computers
broken.
Vandalism: extensive papers and books on the floor
Confiscation: One computer screen was on suggesting that its
hard disk had been taken. A substantial amount of books and
journals seem to be missing although exactly how many (and what
type) cannot as yet be assessed.
4. Ramallah Chamber of Commerce (New Building):
Location: (Nazlat Rukab™s across from Ramallah Post office)
Based on on-site visit when curfew lifted by Director of the Chamber
of Commerce, Mr. Salah Odeh
The Ramallah Chamber of Commerce serves the whole district of
Ramallah. The Chamber of Commerce owns two attached buildings
with the Chamber housed in two floors in the new main building
across from the post office. In the new building a number of offices
were rented out to the private sector (doctor™s clinic, a development
research institute, lawyers office etc¦). The private businesses only
had their doors broken open and were searched. The offices of the
municipality were widely vandalized. There are no working offices of
the C.C. in the adjacent (old) building, which is mainly rented out to
private businesses and associations. The old building suffered
extensive fire damage (see below under NGOs the offices of the
Palestinian Teachers Union).
Damage: External doors blasted, internal doors blasted or
broken down. Smashed computers and Xerox copier, extensive
vandalism
On Sunday March 31st a Contingent of soldiers broke into the
Chamber of Commerce building. They blew down the main entrance
to the five floor building. The front entrance was completely
blackened by the blast. On the 3rd floor, where the offices of the
Chamber of Commerce are located, they also blew open the door
with explosives. The large brass sign at the entrance with the C.C.™s
insignia was shattered completely and the stairwell blackened by
explosive blasts. Inside, the first office they entered suffered the
most damage. Four computers were destroyed (thrown on the
ground and smashed), the Xerox copier was also thrown on the
ground and broken. There was wide-scale vandalism throughout the
other offices with files and papers strewn on the floor. Whether hard
disks or paper files were taken cannot yet be assessed. Furniture in
the president™s office was vandalized. The door to the 5th floor
conference room was blown open but nothing seems to have been
touched inside. Also the door to the roof was broken open but again
there was no other visible damage. Electricity lines throughout the
building were hanging from the ceiling, there is no electricity
functioning in the building.
III. NON- GOVERNMENTAL ORGANIZATIONS (RAMALLAH)
As of this writing we have been able to collect briefs on the
following:
Human Rights Organizations: al Haq, Mattin Group and Mandela
Institute
Development and Relief Organizations: HDIP and Union of Medical
Relief Committees
Charitable Association: Ramallah branch of the YMCA, al Nahda
Women™s Society for the Hearing Impaired
Private Radio and Television Stations: al Quds University
Educational T.V. and Radio and others
1. The Health Development Information Policy Unit (HDIP)
Location: Ramallah Main Street
The Health, Development, Information and Policy Institute (HDIP)
was established in 1989 by a group of experienced researchers and
health practitioners committed to improving the status of health care
for all Palestinians. An independent, non-profit organization, HDIP
specializes in policy research and planning concerning development
issues and health care in Palestine and its publications are widely
used by international and local development agencies and planners.
HDIP also advocates on health care issues relevant to marginalized
groups like women, youth and the disabled. HDIP has served as a
consultant for numerous international organizations, including the
World Bank, the World Health Organization, UNDP, UNICEF and
international and local NGOs.
HDIP is located on Main Street, Ramallah, in the same building
complex that houses the economic development and rights
organzations, Mattin Group, and Al Haq, the West Bank affiliate of
the International Commission of Jurists.All are currently occupied by
IDF soldiers who are using the offices as a base, with tanks
stationed in the Al Ahliyyeh Street crossing Main Street, and barbed
wire preventing access.
On the night of 30 March 2002, a staff member staying in the Al Haq
office reported Israeli soldiers invading the building at 11:20PM and
that both Al Haq and HDIP had been entered by Israeli troops.
Damage: The extent of the damage cannot be assessed as Israeli
troops are currently in control of HDIP offices and environs.
Residents have reported soldiers removing cartons and other items
from the building. HDIP had recently expanded its offices into a very
large space below the current offices of Mattin Group which HDIP
had refurbished and purchased large amounts of new computers,
office equipment and furniture.
2. The Union of Palestinian Medical Relief Committees,
Ramallah
Location: Ramouni Building, Ramallah off Main Street
The Union of Palestinian Medical Relief Committees is a grassroots
community-based health organization founded in 1979 by a group of
Palestinian doctors and health professionals to address the
problems of the decaying and inadequate health infrastructure in the
West Bank and Gaza under Israeli military rule. Now one of the
largest Palestinian non-governmental organization, UPMRC runs 25
permanent primary health care centers, fourteen labs and numerous
mobile health units. Its approach is preventive, with an emphasis on
education and participation. In February 2001, UPMRC won an
award from the World Health Organization.
On 1 April 2002, Israeli tanks shelled the Ramouni Building in
downtown Ramallah and soldiers ordered all the inhabitants out of
the building, which houses a main office and emergency medical
center of the Union of Palestinian Medical Relief Committees
(reported on Haaretz web site of the same day) Doctors, staff and
about fourteen Italian volunteers, including Member of the European
Parliament Louisa Morgantini, were detained by soldiers; television
footage showed some staff made to kneel in a nearby parking lot.
Soldiers entered the building and searched offices.
Damage: At least one shell entered the office of the UPMRC
causing a wall to collapse. The Director of UPMRC, Dr. Mustapha
Barghouti, reported that most equipment was destroyed, including
computers and a photocopier. Access to the Ramouni Building to
access damage in more detail is restricted due to continued army
presence in the area. Other UPMRC facilities invaded by the IDF on
31 March 2002 were the UPMRC Youth Club, the UPMRC
Optometry Center, and the UPMRC Technical Aid for the Disabled
Center.
3. Mandela Institute for Political Prisoners, Ramallah
Description:Mandela Institute for Political Prisoners (named for
Nelson Mandela) was established in 1990 to provide assistance to
political prisoners. Its activities now include the provision of legal
and material aid to prisoners detained by both the Israeli and
Palestinian authorities, and to their families, and the training of
Palestinian police forces in human rights issues.
Type of Damage: The premises of Mandela were occupied for
some days by the Israeli Defense Forces. The following is reported
by a member of Mandela's Board of Directors, who was able to
make one visit to the office during the lifting of curfew.
1. External damage The external metal doors to the building, in
which Mandela's offices are housed, were blown up and completely
destroyed
2. Internal damage VANDALISM: The offices were completely
vandalized. Computers (3 counted) were thrown on the floor, broken
furniture and files from cabinets strewn across the floor. Soldiers
blocked the toilets leading to sewage over-spilling and ruining fitted
carpets. Soldiers defecated in a number of rooms -- the offices are
filthy.
B. CONFISCATION: The hard drive of the main computer has been
removed. Its contents include Mandela's data base. Due to the
imposition of curfew, it has not been possible to check whether
other files or documents have been confiscated or destroyed.
C. STRUCTURAL DAMAGE: The IDF used Mandela's office to fire
into other buildings. As a result 5 office windows were completely
destroyed, including the aluminum frames. All internal doors, which
were locked, were broken into and badly damaged.
Impact on work
Mandela has clearly suffered considerable financial loss due to the
destruction or damage to equipment, furnishings and physical
structure. How much data and documentation has been confiscated
or damaged is impossible to determine under the present curfew.
4. MATTIN Group (Human Rights)
Location: Main Street Ramallah
MATTIN Group is a voluntary partnership specializing in
international human rights and humanitarian law enforcement. It
was occupied on March 29th by the same armored infantry and
sniper force that occupied al-Haq and HDIP, which adjoin it in the
same building.
The main entrance door of the office was torn down on the day after
the army had occupied the premises. Neighbors reported that a
large force had entered MATTIN™s premises and were both carrying
in and bringing out a large quantity of unidentified objects.
During the lifting of the curfew on Tuesday, April 2, one of the senior
staff members of the organization attempted to gain entry into the
office, but was not permitted to do so. Based on a soldier™s
statement, all internal doors, as well as the internal walls connecting
MATTIN™s space with al-Haq and HDIP appear to have been broken
down by the soldiers.
In addition to records, computers, and office equipment, among the
archives the office contains an irreplaceable collection of
unpublished documents, concerning International Humanitarian
Law related diplomacy and other similarly important unpublished
materials accumulated over a 19-year period.
On Monday, April 8, another attempt by a staff member to approach
the office was rebuffed by the army. The office building is blocked by
barbed wire which spans the street on which it is located, and
always guarded by at least two army vehicles, including tanks and
APC™s. Because nobody has been allowed inside the premises, it is
still unclear just how severe the damage to the office is, and what
has been vandalized, confiscated, and looted by the occupation
forces.
5. AL “ HAQ Human Rights Organization
Location: Main Street Ramallah
Description:Founded in 1979, Al -Haq was the first Palestinian
human rights organization to be established in the occupied
territories and is the West Bank affiliate of the International
Commission of Jurists. Through activities, such as monitoring of
human rights violations committed by both the Israeli and
Palestinian Authorities, it has a long and internationally recognized
role in promoting respect for human rights within Palestine.
Type of Damage: This report was given by a staff member of al-
Haq. It is based on two quick visits he made to the offices when the
curfew was lifted.
External Damage: The two front doors broken open and badly
damaged.
Internal Damage:
VANDALISM: Furniture broken and over-turned such as couch and
filing cabinets. Content of filing cabinets scattered all over the floor;
drawers forced open and contents rummaged through or
scattered3 computers and one printer thrown across floor and
broken. Al-Haq has not yet had the opportunity to inspect their
laptops for damage
SANCTIONED THEFT: As yet, can only confirm1 lap top computer
stolen
CONFISCATION: Computer hard drives removed on a number of
computers as well
as internal electronics likewise taken, leaving only the frame.
STRUCTURAL DAMAGE: One window smashed; 3 inner doors
broken open and damaged. Ceiling in places has been smashed
from inside
Impact on work
Al Haq has been working for 24 years and has built up an extensive
archive of documents. The full extent of the impact of this vandalism
on their work depends largely on what can be salvaged from their
records and documents. These are scattered across the floors of
their offices. Due to the curfew on Ramallah, staff have not yet had
the chance to see whether any papers or documents are missing.
6. Ramallah YMCA (Branch of East Jerusalem YMCA)
The YMCAs offices in Ramallah serve not only young people in the
town but it also serves young people in the surrounding villages
through its extensive field programs. It runs a number of important
programs for youth, including vocational training for young women,
vocational counseling for girls in schools, and the career guidance
for young people going into the workplace. It also assists in
constructing community youth centers in surrounding villages.
(Based on preliminary reports issued by the YMCA Main Office in
East Jerusalem and based on accounts of people who either
witnessed some of the destruction, and staff who visited the
premises briefly during the lifting of curfew. It has been impossible
to make a full assessment of the damage due to the ongoing
curfew).
The YMCA's premises in Ramallah comprise three offices.The
building is designated by a large outdoor sign on the building. On 8
April 2002 a contingent of IDF forces blasted open the main
entrance to YMCA building and the guard's office. They badly
destroyed the elevator and there was extensive vandalism in a
number of offices including destruction of equipment (it seems
computers, overheads and other training aids.Reporters for NBC
television living in a neighboring building tried to prevent the
destruction, by repeatedly telling the IDF forces that these were
YWCA premises, funded largely by USAID. The soldiers ignored
them and went on to detonated the garage, destroying also the
vehicles inside: one car and one large van containing valuable
educational material, which was used to tour villages for educational
work.
7. Private Radio and TV Stations
The following is based on an on-site visit when the curfew lifted and
interviews with station managers undertaken by technical consultant
to al Quds educational Media, Wassim Abdullah and excerpted from
an extensive report that he wrote which is now posted at a website
along with pictures of the destruction. See
www.geocities.com/wramallah
There are 5 private TV stations and 5 private radio stations in
Ramallah, as well as the official Palestinian authority radio and TV
stations. Most of these stations are located in and around the town
center, an elevated area suitable for maximum broadcasting
coverage. In the totality of the Palestinian Authority areas there are
almost 50 TV and radio stations, more than in any surrounding
country. This independent media was contributing to the building of
civil society by fostering an appreciation of free media, training in
technical skills and reporting, creating local programming, and
developing an innovative sector. The stations benefited from grants
and support from the international and local community.
A. Al Quds Educational Television
Location: on the third floor of the College of Nursing in al-Bireh, near
the entrance to Ramallah.
The TV station is operated by Al Quds University and broadcasts
children's programs in addition to public service announcements,
medical information and emergency services contact information.
The institution was open and on air with a cartoon show when Israeli
soldiers broke in. Two staff operators were held for several hours,
eventually released and warned not toreturn. Tanks and armored
carriers are still on the campus of the college, preventing anyone
from entering. The station has remained off the air since the
takeover.
External destruction: The 40-watt relay TV transmitter and
microwave receiver atop the Bakri building in the Minara of
Ramallah was destroyed.
Internal destruction: It is assumed that the state-of-the-art studio
and operations center have been completely destroyed, since
soldiers systematically destroyed almost all other TV stations in the
Ramallah-al-Bireh area. Contents of TV studio: cold lighting, super
quiet air conditioning system, cameras, audio and video mixers,
players/recorders, two AVID suites, a computer lab, microwave
studio link and our new 250 watt TV transmitter, a UPS, a
comprehensive children, social and cultural library of films,
computers for the staff complete with audio, video and data
networks, office machines.
B. Al Nasr TV
Total destruction of equipment/extensive vandalism: Microphones,
tapes, CD's, monitors, mixers, players/recorders, etc were found
spread over the floor of the station and completely smashed by
sledgehammers.
C. Manara radio station
Total destruction of equipment, extensive vandalism
D. Ajyal and Angham FM radio stations
Location: Bakri building, Ramallah center
The doorman of the building was forced to open the station door to
soldiers who used sledgehammers to destroy the two studios, the internet
streaming and editing computers, the 10 Kw and 3 Kw transmitters
and the entire music and program library. Destruction was total.
E. Love and Peace FM radio station
Total destruction of equipment/extensive vandalism.
F. Al Quds FM radio station
The building in which it is located was bombarded and set ablaze.
No one has been able to enter the building to assess damage.
Also ceased broadcasting and feared destroyed: Amwaj TV, Amwaj
radio and Al-Watan TV. The buildings where they are situated are
still occupied by Israeli soldiers and no one has been able to enter to
assess damage.
IV. OTHER TOWNS/ VILLAGES:
It has been extremely difficult to access information from most other
towns since they have remained under curfew without break since
they were invaded. Also, many re-occupied towns (Jenin, Tulkarim,
Nablus etc..) have had no electricity or phone lines for the past
week). Below is information on damages to governmental and non-
governmental organizations in areas besides Ramallah. All of the
following information is very preliminary given that it is based on
information from people who have reached sites while the curfew is
still on and thus only a very quick picture could be drawn.
Bethlehem
1.Municipality Building
Location: Manger Square
This report was made by an employee in the emergency services
room set up in the municipality building. He and another 15
emergency workers were in the building when it was invaded by IDF
troops. They were detained for a number of hours within the building
and then taken to a detention center where he and others were
subsequently released. The information he was able to provide was
based on his eyewitness account when the events were underway
and is very preliminary. The IDF continues to occupy the
Municipality building as of April 13th.
Destruction: There has been destruction of many external and
internal doors, as well as many windows smashed. A number of
interior walls of the building have been destroyed.
Destroyed/ vandalized furniture. Approximately twenty mobile
stretchers were taken from the premises; seven of them were
returned severely damaged. Also destroyed were three video
cameras and a cassette inside one of them was confiscated.
Anabta Village (Tulkarm District)
[Employees could make only an initial assessment of damage, due
to the ongoing curfew.]
1. Anabta Municipality
Number of staff: 60
External destruction
The entrance door was completely destroyed.
Internal destruction
VANDALISM: Just before the incursion, the municipality had
transferred some archeological artifacts from Tulkarm fearing that
they might be destroyed; half of the relocated collection was
destroyed. The fire-alarm system, the central telephone system and
individual telephones were destroyed. Municipal files were torn and
thrown on the ground. The entire library, book shelves and books,
were thrown on the floor. Some desks were damaged.
SANCTIONED THEFT: Two municipal computers were taken. In the
library, a computer and a camera were taken.
CONFISCATION: All of the municipality's floppy disks were
removed.
STRUCTURAL DAMAGE: The windows and doors were broken.
(Information supplied by Mayor,Hamdallah Hamdallah; who has
photos and a detailed report on the destruction.)
2. The Anabta Women™s Charitable Organization
This charitable organization has a staff of 11 and offers health
services and social and cultural activities for women, provides relief
for the poor and outreach for the elderly, in addition to operating a
preschool (230 children) and daycare (10 infants).
External damage
The outside wall was blown up with explosives, which also damaged
the building. The gate had several bullet or shrapnel holes in it.
Internal destruction
VANDALISM: There was a great deal of superficial damage. All of
the glass was found broken.
(Information provided by Itaf Al-Qabbaji )
Tulkarim
1. General Union of Palestinian Women, Tulkarim
The Tulkarim branch of the GUPW is engaged in promoting and
marketing embroidery and other traditional handicrafts produced by
village women in the area.
External destruction
The door was blown open with explosives.
Internal destruction
VANDALISM: All drawers were apparently searched and all files
were opened. The office equipment appeared to be intact.
Embroidery had been strewn all over the floor and stepped on.
STRUCTURAL DAMAGE : Windows were broken.
(Information supplied by Fawziyyeh Yahya Aboud)
2. Rawdat Abna™ Al-Ghad
This is a preschool with 6 employees serving 70 children.
External destruction Main door destroyed.
Internal destruction
VANDALISM: All of the children's the toys were thrown on the
ground and many smashed. The wall-to-wall carpeting has been
ripped and in some places removed, the small puppet theater was
destroyed.
(Information supplied by Fawziyyeh Yahya Aboud)
Report Compiled By:
Dr. Rema Hammami, Birzeit University
Dr. Sari Hanafi, Shaml (Refugee and Diaspora Research Center)
Dr. Elizabeth Taylor