|
Sunday Sept. 9, 2012 3:37 PM (EST+7)
ANALYSIS: Can Israel surprise Iran? Maybe not, but could still strike
|
|
|
JERUSALEM, Sept 9 (Dan Williams/Reuters) - Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's cancellation of a security cabinet session on Iran following a media leak last week laid bare a conundrum long troubling Israeli strategists: could they count on any element of surprise in a war on their arch-foe?
|
|
|
 |
 Israeli Air Force F-16 jet fighter in flight over Israel.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Multimedia
 US VP Joseph Biden's speech at Tel Aviv University
March 13, 2010 10:45 AM (EST+7)
Anata farmer injured and Israeli activists assaulted by settlers
Oct. 3, 2011 11:00 AM (EST+7)
al-Jazeera Int: Dining with Terrorists, Fighting Occupation Pt. 1
March 8, 2009 9:03 AM (EST+7)
|
 Documents
 Benjamin Netanyahu‘s speech to AIPAC, March 22, 2010
Hillary Clinton‘s Speech to AIPAC, March 22, 2010
Remarks by President Obama and Prime Minister Netanyahu of Israel, March 6, 2012
|
Publications
Poll No. 59, July 2006 - On Palestinian Attitudes Towards the Abduction of the Israeli Soldier & Firing of Rockets
Poll No. 78, Dec. 2012 - Gaza, Resistance and the UN Bid
Poll No. 25, February 1998 - On Palestinian Position and Attitudes Towards the Current Crisis between Iraq and the United States
|
Background
Egypt wall
Jerusalem
Refugees and internally displaced persons
|
Resources
“Suicide and Other Bombing Attacks in Israel Since the Declaration of Principles (Sept 1993),” Israel Ministry of Foreign Affairs
BBC article on rockets attacks on Kiryat Shmona, August 2006
"Israel accused of 'indiscriminate' use of white phosphorus," The Independent, March 26, 2009
|
|
|
|
Possibly not. Years of public speculation, much of it stoked by official statements in Israel and abroad, about the likelihood and timing of such a conflict have afforded the Iranians plenty of notice to fortify their threatened nuclear facilities and prepare retaliation.
Given the difficulties Israel's jets would face in reaching and returning from distant Iran, as well as their limited bomb loads, losing the option of mounting sneak attacks may seem to have put paid to the very idea of an attack launched without its ally the United States.
Yet experts are not rushing to rule that out. Some believe Israel is still capable of achieving a modicum of surprise, and that in any case it might hope a combination of stealth, blunt force and, perhaps, hitherto untested innovations can deliver victory - even if Iran is on high alert.
Israel, whose technologically advanced military has a history of successful derring-do, might place less importance on catching Iran completely off-guard and instead strike openly and with combined forces, causing disarray among the defenders in hope of delivering enough damage to a select number of targets.
"The probability of achieving surprise is low, but I think the Israelis will count on their technical competence in defense suppression to allow them in," said Walter Boyne, a former U.S. air force officer and a writer on aviation history.
He predicted the Israelis would mesh air raids with a swarm of strikes by ground and naval units, a view echoed by Lynette Nusbacher, senior lecturer in war studies at Britain's Royal Military Academy Sandhurst. She suggested Israel could also incorporate cyber-attacks to blind Iran as an assault began.
"There is no question that Israel can achieve tactical surprise if required," Nusbacher said, differentiating the short-term shock from Iran's long readiness for an attack.
"As long as the direction or timing or form of the attack is unexpected then surprise is possible."
Israel and its Western allies believe Iran is covertly seeking means to build nuclear weapons, while Tehran insists it wants only to generate electricity and medical isotopes. U.S. President Barack Obama says he hopes sanctions and diplomacy will deflect Iranian policy. But Netanyahu and other Israeli leaders have made clear they might soon resort to force.
Nusbacher indicated that pinpoint intelligence and planning might also help Israel overcome Iran's anticipation and counter-measures, making up for limitations on the element of surprise:
"Remember that while the Iranian nuclear facilities are each more or less defended, their locations are known to the metre," she said. "Precision can't entirely make up for surprise.
"But surprise isn't everything."
JITTERS AND CHATTER
Israeli military planners chafe at their civilian compatriots' freewheeling and jittery discourse about a possible confrontation, worried that the Iranians could glean key warnings simply from monitoring Israeli news and social media.
If they do indeed contemplate a solo surprise attack, they may also be concerned that the United States, loath to see a war on the eve of a presidential election and while it still favors a diplomatic solution, could also be tipped off about a strike early enough to insist its Israeli ally stand down.
There were no such problems in 1981, when a squadron of Israeli fighter-bombers took off from the then-occupied Sinai desert to destroy Iraq's atomic reactor, nor in 2007, when Israel launched a similar sortie against Syria out of the blue.
By contrast, experts think Israel would need to dispatch many scores of jets and support aircraft against Iran, and possibly fire ballistic missiles, all difficult to hide from the public in a small country.
Though a media blackout would be allowed under Israeli emergency laws, such sudden and sweeping censorship would be so unprecedented as to telegraph what was meant to go unpublished - and in any event may prove impracticable in today's wired world.
Nonetheless, some other measures could limit exposure, such as choice of timing. The war on Palestinians in the Gaza Strip was launched on Dec. 27, 2008, deep in the Western holiday season and on a Saturday morning, the Jewish sabbath, when Israel's own media pare coverage to a minimum and newsrooms are barely staffed.
Israel is also trying to restrict the circle of those in the know. The number of those privy to the details of Iran planning in the military and government has been kept very small, a depth of secrecy akin to that surrounding Israel's own nuclear programme, which is assumed to include the region's only atomic weapons.
Netanyahu would be legally required to gain security cabinet approval for an attack on Iran. But after a newspaper reported on Wednesday that ministers on the panel had been presented with conflicting intelligence assessments about Iran, a leak that angered Netanyahu, at least one senior leader, Foreign Minister Avigdor Lieberman, called for the 14-member security cabinet to be shrunk in order to ensure more discretion.
For similar ends, Israel may go so far as to temporarily misdirect its own populace, away from talk of imminent attack.
Days before the Gaza blitz, Ehud Barak - defense minister then, as now - made an unusual and unannounced live appearance on a top-rated TV satire show, where he took a roasting with good humor and made sure to give every impression that starting a war could not be further from his mind.
In another deliberate feint intended to wrongfoot the gossips, Israeli generals summoned officers from garrisons around Gaza to a weekend retreat, with their families, at a countryside spa. All but the most senior of those invited commanders were then surprised to be woken up, that Saturday morning, and dispatched back to base for combat within hours.
Asked about such ruses, a senior Israeli official shrugged and told Reuters they were a legitimate tactic for military planners dealing with a democratic society: "Such things are kosher," he said, "when you have a free press and free speech."
And while certainly not advocating the kind of extensive public discussion seen lately in Israel on the prospects for a conflict, the same official saw a counter-intuitive benefit in that such perpetual talk might erode Iran's level of alertness:
"The more you brace to defend yourself, the more tired you get - or you make the mistake of writing off the threat as a bluff," he said. "Perhaps that's the case with Iran." (Writing by Dan Williams; Editing by Jeffrey Heller and Alastair Macdonald)
|
|
|
 |
Log in
Add comment
Rules
( 0 )
|
|
|
|
logindive
|
All comments on blogs are pre-moderated. This means
comments are read before publication to check there
is no obvious breach of the Rules below. Users who
repeatedly break the rules will be blocked from
posting on JMCC.org.
If you become aware of content that breaches these
Rules, please report the abuse using the link on
each blog post.
|
| Rules |
|
Any posting of any message or content by users to
JMCC.org is subject to the following rules.
|
1. Postings must not:
|
a) contain material that is defamatory, abusive,
threatening, obscene, racially or sexually
offensive, in breach of copyright, trademarks or
other intellectual property rights, sexually
explicit or homophobic or in breach of privacy or
confidentiality or which encourages or condones any
illegal or criminal activity or is in any way
unlawful or inappropriate; |
|
b) contain swearing or inappropriate user names; |
|
c) constitute advertising or virus propagation,
provide weblinks that amount to advertising or which
are inappropriate or constitute spamming or
flooding; |
|
d) impersonate any person or entity; |
|
e) solicit or exchange personal information - for
example do not give out your email address, home
address, work place or telephone number or arrange
to meet anyone; |
|
f) be misleading or inaccurate or portray anyone in
a false light; or |
|
g) contain material that is copied or that you do
not own. |
2. You are responsible for liability and any legal
action arising from your posting. You indemnify us
against all losses, claims, damages and expenses
(including the cost of defending or settling any
claim or damages), whether foreseeable or
unforeseeable, suffered or incurred directly or
indirectly arising from your posting.
3. Please be aware that it is possible to trace
internet activity to a specific computer.
4. By submitting a posting to JMCC.org, you grant us
a worldwide royalty free license to use your content
in perpetuity and at our discretion in any media now
known or hereafter developed and you now give us all
waivers (including waivers of moral rights) and
consents to do so.
5. We may refuse to publish and/or remove any
content at any time for any reason at our sole
discretion. If you breach these Rules we may also
prohibit you from submitting further postings to
JMCC.org.
6. We are not responsible or liable for any posting
or for its accuracy.
|
|
|
|
|
Israeli Air Force F-16 jet fighter in flight over Israel.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
To subscribe to free newsletter submit your email |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|